So, I broke out the rust-oleum, and then applied dark walnut stain over the top. It kept the rusty look, but made the color a little more consistent.
The Mod Podge in the "after" pic is still a little white because I was too excited about taking pics to wait for it to dry. I used a table cloth (bought on clearance) for the liner. It was perfect because it's really thick. I love how it turned out! Now to decide where to put it. :) 
And don't forget how the inside looked before. Yikes! Not a great and cozy place to store blankets.
